OAKLAND, Calif.
(By Juliana
Barbassa, AP)
August 11, 2009
— Perched at the
edge of an exam
table, Delmira
Maravilla is
anxious for a
check-up — and
for a timeline
on the
president's
promise of
health care for
all Americans.
She's paying out
of pocket for
the exam, and
like one-third
of Hispanics,
the mother of
nine doesn't
have health
insurance.
Latinos like
this immigrant
from El Salvador
have much to
gain if the
legislation
taking shape in
Washington
passes. Among
the major ethnic
groups, they are
the least likely
to have health
coverage through
work. And
Hispanics often
face language
and cultural
hurdles to
getting
good-quality
health services.
They're far less
likely to have a
regular
health-care
provider, and to
get the kind of
routine
screening that
prevents serious
health problems.
Maravilla knows
how easily her
family's
carefully
calculated
budget can be
overwhelmed by
the cost of
health care: her
6-year-old
daughter's
recent fall
against the edge
of a table set
her back a
devastating
$1,500 in
emergency room
bills. Any
accident, any
unexpected
illness, can be
catastrophic,
she said.
"I would be so
much calmer,
less worried, if
I knew I had
health insurance
for my family,"
she said.
"Health problems
happen to
everyone, but
it's too
expensive for us
who are poor."
Experts say
health
disparities
among ethnic
groups are
great, with one
in three
Hispanics and
one in five
African-Americans
not having
health
insurance,
compared with
one in eight
whites. And as
the recession
deepens, the gap
is growing along
with rising
unemployment and
cuts to
work-sponsored
insurance.
"We can't have
the status quo.
It's just a
disgrace. I
don't know what
other words to
use," said Elena
Rios, president
of the National
Hispanic Medical
Association, a
nonprofit group
that represents
Hispanic
doctors.
Rios was among
the advocates
calling on
legislators to
consider
measures
designed to
bolster care for
Hispanics
through
preventive
medicine, health
education and
increased
diversity in the
medical field.
Jane Garcia, the
CEO of La
Clinica de la
Raza where
Maravilla gets
her checkups,
sees the need
for reform every
time she makes
her rounds.
About 71 percent
of her patients
are Latino; 44
percent are
uninsured, and
that number has
been going up.
New patients
range from the
recently
unemployed to
undocumented
immigrants who
can no longer
get care in
neighboring
Contra Costa
County, where
supervisors
squeezed by a
budget shortfall
voted to cut
services to
them.
"The number of
people
presenting for
services are
really
overwhelming to
the system," she
said. "And more
of them are
coming in
uninsured."
Although the
House bill
represents the
most
comprehensive
effort to date
to extend health
care to all
Americans, there
is a significant
segment of the
population that
will likely be
excluded:
illegal
immigrants.
Pressed by CBS
News' Katie
Couric about
whether they
should be
covered, the
president
responded
simply, "no."
Absent
immigration
reform and a
path to
citizenship,
that would mean
millions could
be left out of
the system.
About 59 percent
of the 11.9
million
undocumented
immigrants
living in the
United States
have no health
insurance,
according to the
Pew Hispanic
Center.
Advocates are
split on whether
to hold out for
reform that
includes them,
or support
change that
would help the
majority of
Hispanics.
"This has always
been in the
elephant in the
room — all of
our families are
mixed, some
documented, some
undocumented,"
said Rios. "But
we're so close
to having health
care reform.
We'd be working
against
ourselves to let
immigration
issues stall the
process."
Others, like
Jennifer Ng'andu,
deputy director
of the National
Council of La
Raza's Health
Policy Project,
believe any plan
that doesn't
include
undocumented
immigrants won't
last. They make
up about 15
percent of the
nation's
approximately 47
million
uninsured.
"If we don't
talk about
integrating
communities that
have been
traditionally
shut out, we're
going to be
talking about
health care
reform again in
15 years," said
Ng'andu, who has
been talking to
legislators and
to health care
advocates on
their behalf.
To proponents of
greater
immigration
controls,
allowing illegal
immigrants to
benefit from
federally
subsidized
health care and
insurance would
go against
enforcement
goals by
legitimizing
their presence.
"They would have
no incentives to
leave," said
Mark Krikorian,
of the Center
for Immigration
Studies.
Undocumented
immigrants are
the majority of
Rogelio
Fernandez's
patients at the
United Health
Centers clinic
in Parlier, a
town of
approximately
12,000 whose
population
swells and dips
with field
workers
following
agriculture's
planting,
pruning and
harvest seasons.
His clinic
provides primary
care on a
sliding-fee
scale and
discounted
medication to
those who need
it. But in this
tough economy,
he's seeing
patients cut
back on visits
and on their
medication
because, without
insurance, they
can't afford
them.
"Unless they are
more inclusive,
these proposals
really won't
help a lot of
our patients,"
said Fernandez.
Studies show
that inadequate
access to
regular, quality
health care that
meets their
language needs
has
consequences.
Hispanics are
suffering
disproportionately
from chronic
diseases such as
diabetes and
getting less
preventive
measures such as
cancer
screenings and
obesity
counseling.
Not taking care
of this
population now
will have real
costs in the
future, said
Rios. Hispanics
make up 15
percent of the
total U.S.
population, but
they represent
25 percent of
children in
preschools and
kindergartens.
"We are at a
time when we
need change, or
we're going to
see an increase
in obesity,
diabetes,
cancers, heart
disease," said
Rios. "It's not
fair to them, to
us, to the
country."