MIAMI
(By Laura Wides-Munoz,
AP) November 27,
2009— Two
fledgling political
action committees
that support
allowing some
illegal immigrants
to become citizens
are raising more
money than their
immigration-control
counterparts,
signaling a possible
fundraising shift
ahead of next year's
congressional races.
Immigrants' List and
ImmigrationPAC, both
established less
than four years ago,
have raised $100,000
combined this
election cycle.
That's a relatively
small amount in the
influential realm of
PACs but still more
than established
groups that back
enforcement-only
policies, who have
seen donations slow
to a trickle.
"Even a small
amount of
pro-immigration
reform PAC money,
pro-immigration
muscle, makes it a
two-sided debate,"
said Tamar Jacoby,
who heads
ImmigrationWorks
USA, a federation of
mostly small and
medium businesses
that support a path
to citizenship for
some illegal
immigrants and
streamlining the
employment visa
process.
The power of PACS
goes far beyond
their direct
contributions to
candidates. They
also wield power by
bundling smaller
donations from
individuals
nationwide and
directing those
funds to politicians
sympathetic to their
causes.
The PACS — formed
by immigration
lawyers and other
immigrant advocates
— are among
pro-immigrant groups
seeing donations on
the rise. Large
foundations are
donating millions to
nonprofits that work
with immigrants,
although that money
can't be used for
campaigns.
Allen Brandstater,
head of the PAC
Americans Against
Illegal Immigration,
acknowledged the
changing mood. His
group, which raised
$850,000 during the
2008 election cycle
for mostly issue ads
and mailers, the
most of any of the
immigration PACs, is
"pretty much dormant
right now," he said.
Brandstater blamed
the lack of support
on the weak economy
and on President
Barack Obama and the
Democratic-led
Congress, which he
believes are more
likely to back
legalization.
Brandstater also
lamented that some
donors have grown
wary about
associating
themselves with his
organization because
of what he said was
negative publicity
in 2008.
"In the last
election, you were
called racist if you
wanted to protect
the sovereignty of
our borders," he
said.
Miami-based
immigration attorney
Ira Kurzban
co-founded
Immigrants' List,
the nation's first
major PAC to support
legalization and
other efforts to
help U.S. residents
and asylum seekers,
in 2006. Kurzban
says he looked
around and saw
nearly half a dozen
political
fundraising groups
dedicated to
enforcement-only
immigration policies
that appeared to
have the ears of
lawmakers.
Two years later,
immigrant advocates
in Illinois started
ImmigrationPAC, now
run by the Raben
Group, a New
York-based lobbying
firm.
So far this
election cycle,
Immigrants' List and
ImmigrationPac have
raised $81,000,
compared to about
$71,000 by three
enforcement-only
committees,
according to Federal
Election Commission
data compiled by the
nonprofit Center for
Responsive Politics.
That's minuscule
compared to the
National Rifle
Association's PAC,
which has $7.4
million in the same
period, or to the
financial might on
both sides of the
health care debate.
Still, Jacoby
said she is seeing
growing cash support
from businesses. And
major donors such as
the Ford Foundation,
the Carnegie
Corporation and
liberal financier
George Soros' Open
Society Institute
have also allocated
more to immigrant
advocates and their
allies.
Maria Teresa
Rojas, who manages
the Open Society
Institute's
immigration
portfolio, said her
foundation alone has
allocated an extra
$15 million to be
spent over the next
three years "to take
advantage of what
looks to be a
historic opportunity
to reform our
immigration system."
She cited the
combination of a
Democratic president
and Congress.
Kurzban's group
would like amnesty
for those already in
the U.S.; waivers
for laws that
automatically bar
illegal immigrants
from returning to
the U.S.; statutes
of limitation on
some low-level
crimes; overhaul of
the visa system to
accommodate changing
demand (such as
allowing India to
have a few more
spots than
Switzerland);
permission for
illegal immigrants
married to U.S.
residents to adjust
their status; and
greater judicial
oversight of rogue
immigration agents.
Winning on any of
those points will be
a challenge.
Enforcement-only
PACs have been
operating in
Washington since the
early 1990s. And
there's no clear
sign that the
Democratic-led
Congress has the
stomach for a tough
immigration debate
any time soon,
though the Obama
administration has
signaled that it
wants to take up the
issue next year.
Amy Novick, who
heads Immigrants'
List, said she is
preparing for a long
fight. Most of the
initial donors to
the committee were
immigration lawyers.
Now the group is
looking to take a
page out of the
Obama campaign
playbook, tapping
into small, online
contributors.
"There are tens of
thousands of people
in the U.S.,
citizens and
residents, who have
been touched by the
immigration system,"
Novick said. "Their
spouses, siblings,
children may be here
legally but may be
stuck in the backlog
and need relief."